Epigenetic Regulation by Prions challenges Neo-Darwinism


Article "A Prion Epigenetic Switch Establishes an Active Chromatin State":

Epigenetic Regulation by Prions: A Novel Mechanism for Gene Expression Control

The intricate interplay between genes and the environment shapes the development, physiology, and adaptability of organisms. Epigenetic mechanisms, modifications that alter gene expression without changing the underlying DNA sequence, as per neo-Darwinism, play a crucial role in this dynamic interplay. Among these epigenetic regulators, prions, self-propagating protein misfolds, have emerged as intriguing players, challenging conventional notions of gene regulation.

The study delves into the uncharted territory of prion-mediated epigenetic regulation, uncovering a novel mechanism by which prions influence gene expression. The authors focus on Snt1, a protein scaffold that forms part of the Set3C histone deacetylase complex, a key regulator of chromatin structure and gene expression.

Prion-Induced Gene Activation: A Paradigm Shift

The study reveals that Snt1 can undergo a prion transition, adopting an altered conformation known as [ESI+]. This prion state, triggered by transient Snt1 phosphorylation upon cell cycle arrest, instigates a remarkable shift in Snt1's function. Instead of repressing gene expression, as is its native role, [ESI+] Snt1 promotes active transcription of genes typically silenced in subtelomeric regions of the genome.

Mechanism of Prion-Mediated Activation: A Tale of Recruitment and Exclusion

The authors unravel the mechanism underlying this transcriptional activation. They demonstrate that the [ESI+] prion conformation alters Snt1's ability to interact with other proteins, leading to a cascade of events that favor gene expression. Key to this process is the recruitment of RNA polymerase II, the enzyme responsible for transcribing DNA into RNA, to the previously repressed genes. Additionally, the [ESI+] prion interferes with the binding of Rap1, a repressor protein that normally silences these genes.

Transgenerational Inheritance: A Legacy of Prion-Mediated Gene Expression

A remarkable aspect of this study is the demonstration that the [ESI+] prion state can be stably inherited across generations of cells. This transgenerational inheritance ensures that the activated transcriptional state persists, potentially providing a long-term adaptive advantage to the organism.

Stress Response: A Prion-Mediated Adaptive Strategy

The study also sheds light on the potential role of prions in stress response. The [ESI+] prion state confers resistance to various environmental stresses, including antifungal drugs. This suggests that prions may serve as an adaptive mechanism, enabling cells to cope with changing environmental conditions.

Implications and Future Directions

The findings of this study significantly expand our understanding of prion biology and their impact on gene regulation. The discovery of a prion-mediated epigenetic mechanism that promotes gene activation challenges conventional paradigms and opens new avenues for exploring the role of prions in development, disease, and adaptation. Future research endeavors should focus on elucidating the molecular details of prion-mediated gene regulation and exploring the broader implications of prions in epigenetic landscapes.

The article challenges neo-Darwinism in several ways.

1. Non-genetic inheritance

Neo-Darwinism is based on the idea that evolution occurs through the natural selection of heritable traits. However, the prion described in this article can be inherited without any changes to the DNA sequence. This suggests that there may be other mechanisms of inheritance that are not accounted for by neo-Darwinism.

2. Epigenetic change

Neo-Darwinism is focused on changes to the DNA sequence, but epigenetics is the study of how the environment can change gene expression without changing the DNA sequence. The prion described in this article is an epigenetic switch that can turn genes on or off. This suggests that epigenetics plays a more important role in evolution than previously thought.

3. Heritable plasticity

Neo-Darwinism is based on the idea that organisms are adapted to their environment. However, the prion described in this article can cause organisms to become more resistant to environmental stress. This suggests that organisms may have more heritable plasticity than previously thought, and that they may be able to adapt to new environments more quickly than neo-Darwinism allows.

4. Adaptive value

The prion described in this article can confer an adaptive advantage on organisms. This suggests that there may be other mechanisms of adaptation besides natural selection that are not accounted for by neo-Darwinism.

Overall, the implications of the article challenges neo-Darwinism by providing evidence for non-genetic inheritance, epigenetic change, heritable plasticity, and adaptive value. These findings suggest that evolution may be more complex than previously thought, and that neo-Darwinism may need to be revised or replaced to account for these new phenomena.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Beyond the Sequence: The Epigenetic "Fingers" That Play the DNA Keyboard

Image
Imagine the keyboard itself is not a standard piano keyboard, but a modular synthesizer, capable of producing an almost infinite array of sounds. The DNA sequence, then, represents the fundamental building blocks of this synthesizer, the raw materials from which all sounds are generated. Epigenetics, our "fingers," manipulates these building blocks, adjusting parameters like volume, timbre, and rhythm, transforming the raw potential of the DNA sequence into a symphony of cellular functions. We can further refine the "fingers" analogy. Consider that each finger represents a distinct epigenetic mechanism: DNA methylation, histone modifications, and non-coding RNA.  DNA methylation, for instance, might be the "index finger," capable of precisely silencing specific genes, like muting individual keys on the synthesizer. Histone modifications, the "middle finger," could represent the ability to adjust the accessibility of the DN...
Read more

Why are Christian philosophers running towards Darwin while biologists are "running" away?

Image
As nature reveals the strength of epigenetics and the weakness of Neo-Darwinism, biologists are “running” away from the long-standing accepted theory. In The Federalist , April 2019, Benjamin Dierker reviews “Why one-third of biologists now question Darwinism”: "Current estimates are that approximately one-third of professional academic biologists who do not believe in intelligent design find Darwin’s Theory inadequate to describe all of the complexity in biology.” Dierker continues, “The important note is that these are not ideologues or religious zealots, nor do they propose a god or biblical solution.  Rather, they find problems in the lack of explanatory power of Darwin’s theory in light of modern understanding of mutation, variation, DNA sequencing and more. These expressions of doubt do not reject naturalism or evolution per se, but the rigor of the Neo-Darwinian model for explaining the development of life.” For 40 years, scientists calculated natural se...
Read more

Rewriting the Rules: Epigenomic Mutation Bias Challenges Randomness in Evolution

Image
This research challenges the long-held dogma that mutations occur randomly, irrespective of their consequences, by demonstrating a clear, epigenome-mediated mutation bias in Arabidopsis thaliana . The study meticulously unveils how mutation rates are not uniform across the genome but are significantly reduced in functionally constrained regions, particularly within gene bodies and essential genes. This discovery fundamentally alters our understanding of evolutionary processes, suggesting that mutation is not a purely directionless force. "Mutation bias reflects natural selection in Arabidopsis thaliana" This opening statement encapsulates the core finding: mutation rates are not random but reflect epigenetic pressures. The authors demonstrate that mutations are less frequent in crucial genomic regions, directly contradicting the prevailing theory of random mutation. This observation suggests an active mechanism that minimizes deleterious mutations in essentia...
Read more